Home » Blog » Short-Term vs Long-Term Rentals: Which Strategy Makes More Money?

Short-Term vs Long-Term Rentals: Which Strategy Makes More Money?

Posted on March 27, 2025Posted in propertyNo Comments

The Million-Dollar Question – Short-Term or Long-Term Rentals?

Imagine this: You own a stunning beachfront condo in Santa Cruz. Do you rent it out nightly to vacationers soaking up the sun, or lease it long-term to a local professional seeking stability? Both options promise cash flow—but which one truly maximizes your profits?

Here’s a striking fact: According to the National Association of Realtors (NAR), 23% of all U.S. renters now live in single-family homes, reflecting a growing demand for rental properties.

This surge highlights the lucrative potential of both rental strategies—especially in high-demand areas like Santa Cruz and the Bay Area. But choosing between what is considered short term rental and what is considered long term rental can be tricky.

Do you prefer the excitement of nightly bookings or the reliability of steady monthly income? By the end, you’ll know which strategy suits your goals best.

What Is Considered a Short-Term Rental?

A short-term rental is a stay from one night to under 30 days. Think chic lofts for weekend getaways, cabins for family trips, or urban apartments during events. These aren’t just spaces—they’re experiences.

Flexibility Meets Profit: Owners love the ability to rent on their terms while charging nightly rates that far exceed traditional leases.
Travelers Want More: Modern renters are ditching hotels for unique, homey spaces that reflect local charm and personal style.
Massive Market Growth: The global short-term rental market is exploding, with projections estimating it will hit a jaw-dropping USD 341.9 billion by 2033, growing at an impressive 11.2% CAGR. For property owners in high-demand areas like Santa Cruz or the Bay Area, this is your golden ticket to cashing in on the trend.

Understanding what is considered a short term rental isn’t just about staying relevant—it’s about seizing a booming opportunity. Are you ready to tap into the action?

Pros and Cons of Short-Term Rentals: The Highs and Lows

Short-term rentals can feel like a goldmine one day and a headache the next. Let’s break it down—here’s what you need to know before diving in.

Why You’ll Love Short-Term Rentals (The Upside)

Big Bucks Per Night: Earn 2-3x more per night compared to long-term leases. Perfect for high-demand areas like Santa Cruz or the Bay Area.
Flexibility on Your Terms: Use your property whenever you want—ideal for second homeowners who crave personal access.
Seasonal Cash Boosts: Capitalize on peak seasons, holidays, and local events when demand spikes.
Stand Out with Style: Design unique spaces that attract travelers willing to pay top dollar for a memorable stay.

Why You Might Think Twice (The Downside)

Hands-On Hustle: Managing bookings, cleaning, restocking, and guest issues is time-consuming and exhausting.
Unpredictable Income: Occupancy rates can swing wildly based on seasonality, competition, or even bad weather.
Regulatory Roadblocks: Cities like San Francisco and Santa Cruz have strict rules, permits, and caps on short-term rentals.
Hidden Costs Add Up: Cleaning fees, platform commissions (like Airbnb’s cut), and maintenance can eat into your profits faster than you think.

Pros	Cons
Higher nightly rates (2-3x long-term leases)	Fluctuating occupancy rates
Flexibility for personal use	Time-intensive management
Peak season windfalls	Strict local regulations
Creative freedom to design unique spaces	Hidden costs (cleaning, fees, upkeep)

Short-term rentals can be a lucrative option, but they’re not for everyone. If you’re ready to hustle and navigate the ups and downs, the rewards can be worth it. But if you prefer stability and ease, this might not be your golden ticket.

Financial Showdown: Short-Term vs. Long-Term Rentals

Let’s compare two scenarios—one in an urban hotspot and one in a suburban neighborhood—to see how short-term and long-term rentals stack up financially, factoring in cleaning, repairs, utilities, and vacancy rates.

Example 1: Urban Hotspot – Downtown Condo

Short-Term Rental: $200/night
Long-Term Rental: $2,000/month

Metric	Short-Term Rental	Long-Term Rental
Monthly Income	$4,800 (at 60% occupancy)	$2,000
Annual Income	$57,600	$24,000
Expenses	Cleaning ($3,000), Maintenance ($1,500), Platform Fees ($4,000)	Maintenance ($1,500)
Net Profit	$49,100	$22,500

Key Takeaways for Urban Properties :

Short-term rentals can generate nearly double the annual profit compared to long-term leases.
However, they come with higher operational costs and require constant management.
Urban hotspots like San Francisco or Santa Cruz are perfect for short-term rentals due to high tourist demand.

Example 2: Suburban Neighborhood – Family Home

Short-Term Rental: $150/night
Long-Term Rental: $1,800/month

Metric	Short-Term Rental	Long-Term Rental
Monthly Income	$3,150 (at 50% occupancy)	$1,800
Annual Income	$37,800	$21,600
Expenses	Cleaning ($2,000), Maintenance ($1,200), Platform Fees ($3,000)	Maintenance ($1,200)
Net Profit	$31,600	$20,400

Key Takeaways for Suburban Properties :

Short-term rentals still outperform long-term leases but by a smaller margin.
Lower occupancy rates and fewer tourists in suburban areas make long-term rentals more appealing.
Long-term rentals offer stability and lower management headaches, making them ideal for suburban neighborhoods.

The Role of Location in Your Decision

Urban Hotspots = Short-Term Goldmines: High tourist traffic and premium nightly rates make cities like Santa Cruz or San Francisco perfect for short-term rentals.
Suburban Areas = Long-Term Sweet Spots: Families and professionals seeking stable housing favor long-term leases, making them a better fit for quieter neighborhoods.

Which Strategy Wins Financially?

Scenario	Best Option	Why?
Urban Property	Short-Term Rental	Higher demand, bigger profits (despite costs).
Suburban Property	Long-Term Rental	Stability and lower operational burdens.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on location and your management style. Short-term rentals bring bigger profits but require hustle, while long-term rentals offer stability and peace of mind.

Key Factors to Decide Your Rental Strategy

Choosing between short-term and long-term rentals isn’t just about numbers—it’s about aligning your property with your goals, lifestyle, and market realities. Here’s what you need to consider before making the call:

Location: Tourist hubs like Santa Cruz favor short-term rentals; residential areas are better for long-term leases. Location is key.
Your Style: Are you a hands-on hustler or a laid-back investor? Short-term rentals require effort; long-term offer stability.
Market Demand: Travelers vs. tenants—research local trends. Tech hubs and tourist spots drive demand differently.
Legal Rules: Check local laws. Some cities ban short-term rentals or cap rental days, while others favor long-term leases.
Your Goals: Flexibility or consistency? Choose based on what aligns with your personal priorities.

Your rental strategy is as unique as your property—and your personality. Whether you’re chasing excitement or craving calm, the right choice depends on seamlessly blending these factors.

Tips to Crush It With Either Strategy

Whether you’re leaning toward short-term or long-term rentals, these tips will set you up for success and help you maximize your returns.

For Short-Term Rentals:

Stage Like a Pro: Create an Instagram-worthy space that wows guests and boosts your appeal.
Dynamic Pricing: Use tools like Beyond Pricing or Wheelhouse to adjust rates based on demand and maximize profits.
Go the Extra Mile: Offer welcome baskets, local guides, or discounts to earn glowing reviews and repeat bookings.

For Long-Term Rentals:

Screen Tenants Smartly: Avoid headaches by thoroughly vetting tenants to ensure reliability.
Maintain and Modernize: Keep your property in top shape to retain tenants and reduce turnover.
Build a Support Network: Partner with trusted contractors for quick fixes and emergencies.

Conclusion: Finding the Right Fit for Your Investment

Short-term rentals offer high earning potential and flexibility but demand more effort and come with regulatory challenges. Long-term rentals provide stability, predictable income, and fewer headaches but may mean missing out on peak profits. Understanding the difference between short term and long term rental strategies is key to making the right decision.

Still unsure? Let Streamline Property Management guide you. We maximize your rental income and handle the heavy lifting—marketing, maintenance, and more. Whether you’re in Santa Cruz or the Bay Area, we’ve got the expertise to help you succeed.

Ready to unlock your property’s potential? Contact Streamline831 today for stress-free property management. Your success starts here.

Questions? We have Answers

What permits do I need for short-term rentals in Santa Cruz?

Santa Cruz requires a Short-Term Rental Permit, along with adherence to noise ordinances and safety regulations. Streamline can help you navigate this process.

How does Streamline handle tenant disputes for long-term rentals?

Our team mediates disputes professionally, ensuring fair resolutions while protecting your interests. We also provide legal guidance when necessary.

How much can I earn with a short-term rental in Santa Cruz?

Earnings vary based on location and seasonality, but properties in high-demand areas like the beachfront can generate 2-3x more than long-term leases. Streamline Property Management helps optimize pricing for maximum profitability.

Can Streamline manage my property if I live out of state?

Yes! We specialize in remote property management, handling everything from tenant screening to maintenance so you can invest confidently without being local.

What’s the typical vacancy rate for long-term rentals in the Bay Area?

Vacancy rates are typically low (under 5%) due to high demand, but this varies by neighborhood. Streamline Property Management minimizes vacancies through targeted marketing and tenant retention strategies.